CDS Environmental Electrics
Energy Efficiency Recommended CDS Environmental Electrics
Supplier of Environmental White Goods
Maintenance & Repair
European Ecolabel

Dish Washer Comparison Matrix

The brands and models selected have been chosen as typical dish washing machine products available in the marketplace today. The purpose of the comparison is to suggest a method to help choose a product with the lowest overall environmental impact (OEI) and meet practical needs. This requires achieving a balance between cost and application requirements. The principles discussed apply to other brands and models.

A measure of the environmental impact is summarised in the following dish washing machine performance ratings in three categories: Energy, Wash and Dry. Each category is in-turn assigned a letter A+,A,B,C,D,E,F,G providing a scale of relative damage to the environment. The letter A+ environmental rating indicates the lowest level of damage to the environment and at the other end of the scale the letter G environmental rating indicates highest level of damage to the environment. An example for a typical dish washing machine performance is given as: Energy: A; Wash: A; Dry: A

The combined environmental rating may be written in the order: (Energy)(Wash)(Dry). In this example the combined rating is AAA. In the comparison matrix below, the column marked Rating, follows this convention.

To get a single numerical measure of the overall environmental impact (OEI), we assign a number to each letter: A+=1/2, A=1, B=2, C=3, D=4, E=5, F=6, G=7. The the overall environmental impact score of a dish washing machine may then be expressed as a multiple of the rating in each of the three categores: OEI = (Energy)x(Wash)x(Dry). In our example, OEI = (A)x(A)x(A) = (1)x(1)x(1) = 1. The larger the OEI score, the more damaging the environmental impact. The lower the OEI score, the less damaging the environmental impact. A score of OEI=1 or less than 1 is the environmental recommended objective. In addition, some dishwashers have 'ACQUATEST' - an extra sensor which minimises the consumption of water. All AAA rated machines are compliant with the Energy Efficiency Endorsement Scheme.

ACQUATEST Acquatest: An electronic infrared sensor measures the clarity of the incoming water from the tank. At pre-determined intervals the electronic board decides whether to continue with the pre-wash cycle or to move on to heat the water for the wash programme. Dishwashers with the Aquatest feature are able to keep consumption of water and energy to a minimum, depending on the the degree of dirt on the dishes.
Energy Saving Energy Efficiency: The Energy Saving Trust has been set up to monitor companies, and register models that fully comply with the strict parameters set out by the Energy Efficiency Endorsement Scheme. Only AAA rated appliances can be registered with the scheme, and display the logo (shown on the left).

Brand Model Price(£) OEI Rating Place Settings Acquatest Water(L) Eco/Bio Wash W&D Time(min) Noise(dB) Warranty Special Offers
ELECTRA E4810AL £385 1 AAA 12 No 15       1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
E4810W £375 1 AAA 12 No 14       1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
     
HOTPOINT FDW60 £380 1 AAA 12 No   Yes     1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
FDW75 £365 1 AAA 12 No   Yes     1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
FDW80 £395 1 AAA 12 No       46 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
FDW85 £295 1 AAA 12 No       46 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
SDW80 £335 1 AAA 9 No     40   1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
SDW85 £351 1 AAA 9 No     40   1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
     
SMEGUK BL4 £1895 1 AAA 14 Yes 15 Yes 160 45 1yr parts+labour Yes
DF41 £535 1 AAA 10 Yes 13 Yes 175 48 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
DF410BL £495 1 AAA 10 Yes 13 Yes 175 48 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
DF61 £675 1 AAA 10 Yes 15 Yes 160 47 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
DF614FAS £665 1 AAA 14 No 15 Yes 180 49 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes
DF6FABR £389 1 AAA 14 Yes 15 Yes 180 45 1yr parts+labour, 5yr parts Yes

NOTE: TBA - to be advised. W&D Time: Washing and Drying time inclusive
Prices exclude VAT. Installation Free. Delivery Free subject to region & Free Extras - see Special Offer.

It is important to point out that all models shown in the table have an OEI value no greater than 1. This indicates that all models meet the recommended environmental criteria.

In this limited comparison, all dishwashers have the same low OEI value of 1. The rows highlighted in green indicate the best environmental choice combining the rating, lowest volume of water consumed and the Acquatest facility for mid-range loading of 10 place sttings. Hence Smeguk models DF41 and FD410BL have a distinct advantage if price is not the prime consideration and other features are not paramount. Of course, if particular features are required such as increased loading - more place settings, other models offered then become more competitive.

CDS Environmental Electrics offers a wide range of popular brands and models in addition to those listed above. If you would like to contact us, we will be pleased to discuss your particular requirements to help you choose a machine with good environmental credentials, style and cost that meet your needs. Enquiry Form


Products

Copyright © 2007 CDS Electrics. All Rights Reserved.

CDS Environmental Electrics
7 Aylesford Grove, Monkston
Milton Keynes MK10 9JE

Tel: 01908 660314  Mobile: 0788 214 8912
Email

Web Site Design by Davis Rubin Associates Limited.